Thanksgiving, Genocide, and the Psychology of Historical Erasure
Every November, American children learn the heartwarming story of the Pilgrims and Native Americans sitting down to share a meal. There are construction-paper feathers, handprint turkeys, and smiling faces around a table. Everyone gets along, everyone is grateful, and apparently, everyone lives happily ever after. It's a lovely story. There's just one problem. It's not the whole story. Not even close.
Long before the Mayflower arrived, Indigenous peoples had been living on and caring for these lands for thousands of years. They had communities, governments, agricultural traditions, and relationships with the land that extended across generations. The settlers didn't discover an empty wilderness. They arrived in someone else's home. As United American Indians of New England (UAINE) explains, the Pilgrims survived in large part because of the Wampanoag people. But what followed that famous meal was not the lasting friendship we were taught to imagine. It was generations of land theft, displacement, violence, and efforts to destroy Indigenous communities.
In 1637, English colonial forces and their Native allies attacked a Pequot village at Mystic, killing hundreds of people, including women and children. The Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center documents the massacre and the devastating impact of the Pequot War. Colonial authorities even declared days of thanksgiving following military victories against Indigenous peoples. Somehow, that part never made it into the school play.
And the violence didn't end there. In 1830, the Indian Removal Act paved the way for the forced displacement of Indigenous nations from their ancestral homelands in the southeastern United States. Thousands of Cherokee people, along with members of the Muscogee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, and Seminole nations, were forced westward. The Cherokee Nation's own historical accounts describe the suffering and deaths that accompanied the forced removal now remembered as the Trail of Tears. Families were driven from their homes, separated from their communities, and forced to travel hundreds of miles. Thousands died from disease, exposure, and the conditions of removal.
What made this possible was not simply military force or government policy. It was also the way Indigenous peoples were portrayed. They were called savages. Their cultures were described as inferior, their presence an obstacle to expansion, and their removal presented as necessary for progress. Dehumanization helped make displacement acceptable to those who stood to benefit from it.
I remember when my daughter came home from school in eighth grade after learning about the Trail of Tears. She was sobbing. "They called them savages," she told me. "Just like they call us terrorists." I have never forgotten that moment. She was still a child, but she recognized something that many adults spend their lives refusing to see. The words and histories were different, but their purpose was painfully familiar. When an entire population is portrayed as dangerous or less deserving of humanity, it becomes easier to justify what is done to them. My daughter wasn't simply learning about someone else's history. She was recognizing something about our own.
This is where liberation psychology gives us something important to think about. Ignacio Martín-Baró believed that we cannot understand people's experiences without understanding the historical and political conditions that shape their lives. He emphasized recovering historical memory, particularly for communities whose stories have been silenced or rewritten. But there's another side to historical memory that I find particularly interesting. Why do we hold on so tightly to stories we know are incomplete? Psychologically, we like to think well of ourselves. We also like to think well of the communities and countries we belong to. When history challenges that image, it's often easier to soften the details, explain them away, or leave them out altogether. A friendly dinner is much easier to celebrate than centuries of colonization.
The trouble is that when we leave out the uncomfortable parts, we don't just change how we remember the past. We change how we understand the present. And for me, this isn't simply an observation about history. It is part of my own family's story.
My father was twelve years old when he was displaced from Ayn Karim during the Nakba of 1948, our own history of forced displacement. He was a child who had a home, a village, and a life that existed long before anyone decided he no longer belonged there. Like the Indigenous families forced from their homelands during the Trail of Tears, Palestinian families were uprooted from places where generations had lived, worked, cultivated the land, and buried their loved ones. The histories are distinct, but the experience of being told that your home is no longer yours is painfully familiar.
Growing up in the Palestinian diaspora meant inheriting a relationship with a place I had not experienced in the same way my father had. Ayn Karim was not simply a village on a map. It was part of our family's history, something that existed in the stories he told and in the memories he carried. When I eventually returned to Ayn Karim with my own family, I understood that returning was about more than visiting a place. It was about reconnecting generations that displacement had separated from their homeland.
I think about what it meant for my father to leave as a child and what it meant for me to return with my children. I think about the land, the trees, the familiar plants, and the knowledge that existed there long before 1948. And I think about how easily those relationships disappear from historical accounts when the people who lived them are no longer the ones telling the story.
I also think about the children of Gaza, whose experiences of loss, displacement, and destruction are unfolding before us. What stories will be told about them fifty or a hundred years from now? Will their experiences be remembered as they lived them, or will someone eventually find a more comfortable way to tell their story? Will their descendants have to explain, as so many Indigenous and Palestinian families have, that their ancestors were not simply people who appeared in someone else's history, but people who had homes, communities, traditions, and futures of their own?
That is the power of historical memory. It allows us to recognize patterns across generations and across the world, even when the circumstances are different. But historical memory isn't only about remembering what happened to people. It's about remembering who they were, who they are, and what they continue to carry forward. Indigenous communities are still here, protecting their languages, traditions, and relationships with their lands. Palestinians continue to preserve village histories, cultivate ancestral crops, practice tatreez, and teach their children about places they may never have visited. These aren't simply reminders of what was lost. They are ways of making sure that what remains continues.
Since 1970, United American Indians of New England has organized a National Day of Mourning in Plymouth, Massachusetts. The observance began after Wamsutta Frank James, an Aquinnah Wampanoag leader, was prevented from delivering a speech challenging the familiar Thanksgiving narrative. Imagine inviting an Indigenous man to speak about his people's history and then deciding that his version is too uncomfortable to hear. Apparently, historical erasure comes with a speaking program. The National Day of Mourning reminds us that Indigenous history did not end with colonization. These communities continue to exist, resist, and shape their own futures.
And perhaps that is what liberation psychology asks of us. Not simply to remember what happened, but to ask why certain stories are celebrated while others are pushed aside. I have no objection to gathering with family, sharing a meal, or expressing gratitude. I rather enjoy all three, particularly when someone else does the cooking. But gratitude should not require historical amnesia. We can teach our children about the Wampanoag without pretending their history ended in 1621. We can acknowledge genocide without reducing Indigenous peoples to their suffering. And we can recognize the connections between Indigenous struggles across the world while respecting their distinct histories.
Because colonization does not end when the violence stops. Its consequences remain in the land, in the institutions, and in the stories we tell about ourselves. And liberation begins, in part, when people reclaim the right to remember and tell their own histories. Perhaps this Thanksgiving, alongside the familiar expressions of gratitude, we can make room for something else.
The truth.
There should always be room for that at the table.

